As Mitch and Matt lay in the darkness in Louis’ living room on the lumpy sleeper sofa, Mitch tossed and turned, trying to get comfortable. Matt had passed out the moment his head touched the pillow but Mitch was having trouble getting to sleep. Eventually his movement roused Matt.
“What’s wrong, Mitch?” Matt asked sleepily.
“Oh, it’s nothing,” Mitch replied.
“No, I can tell there’s something bothering you.”
“Really, don’t worry about it.”
“Mitch, c’mon. This is Matt here. You can tell me anything.”
“Oh, alright,” Mitch relented. “I’m worried I didn’t lock the front door of my house when we left.”
“That’s it?” Matt laughed. “That’s what’s bothering you?”
“It’s a very valid worry,” Mitch said. “Don’t laugh at me.”
“But Mitch, we all watched you lock your front door. You had each of us sign an affidavit attesting to the fact that we had witnessed the locking of the door and had tested the security of the door and that, to the best of our knowledge, the door was locked.”
“I know, it’s just –”
“And then you had pictures taken of you locking the door. And you had a large banner made up stating that the door was indeed locked and you made smaller, keychain-sized versions made as well and gave one to each of us.”
“I know, Matt but –”
“And then you recorded yourself saying, ‘I locked the door. I locked the door,’ over and over again, hundreds of times and you’ve been playing that tape on your Walkman the whole time we’ve been gone.”
“I know, I know, Matt. And still I think about it all the time. Locking the door is such an automatic, brainless act and I forced it into the realm of the conscious. In fact, by calling so much attention to it, I forced it into the super-conscious. And now I’m doubting that it ever happened.”
“What?” Matt asked, confused.
“Yeah, I don’t know if it ever happened of if my brain’s just fooling me into thinking that it happened.”
“I was there, Mitch,” Matt said. “Trust me, it happened. And it was pretty sad, too.”
“How do I know you’re not making that up?”
“Why would I do that? Cripes, Mitch. You’re off your rocker. Good night.”
“No, seriously Matt. How do I know you’re not just making this whole story up? And that my memory of locking the door has been placed in my head through the power of suggestion? That is to say that simply by hearing your repeated telling of the story of the locking of my door, it has actually become a memory of my own.”
“What about the banner? The photos? The cassette?”
“Props? Fakes? Figments? What is memory, anyway? What’s your earliest memory, Matt?” Mitch asked.
Matt thought about it for a moment and then replied, “Throwing up on my mom at a black-tie dinner at the United Nations when I was two years old.”
“Are you sure?”
“Sure, I remember it like it was yesterday.”
“Isn’t that the sort of story your mom might tell over and over again?” Mitch asked.
Matt snorted, “C’mon, Mitch. You’ve met my mom. Does she seem like the type of woman who’d tell an amusing anecdote about being puked on in front of Boutros-Boutros Gali?”
“Now that you mention it, no, she doesn’t. But it is the sort of story that you’d tell. Especially every time someone says the U.S. should pay its late fees for its U.N. membership. You love telling that story.”
“What’s your point?”
“Well, you’ve told the story so much, and you’ve hear me tell it a few times, and I’m sure you’ve got other friends you’ve heard tell it.”
“Sure. And?”
“Well, how do you know it’s a real memory and not just a story? Is there actual recollection of an event or are you just remembering a retelling?”
“Wow, Mitch. I think I’m starting to see your point. You don’t know if you remember locking your door or if you remember a story in which you locked your door.”
“Exactly,” replied Mitch. “And therefore, I’m having trouble sleeping.”
“Well now I am too,” said Matt.
“How come?” asked Mitch.
“Because I’m worried that I didn’t plug the drain in the houseboat and the whole thing’s going to be underwater when we get back.”
“That would suck.”
“Tell me about it,” Matt replied sadly.
“Wanna play flashlight tag?” Mitch asked.
“Would I ever!” Matt exclaimed.
“Keep it down out there!” Louis shouted from his bedroom. “I gotta work in the morning!”
“Sorry, Louis!” Matt and Mitch said together.
Even though they were forced to muffle their cries of glee and delight, it was the best game of flashlight tag either man had ever played.
-
Recent
Archive
Categories